The secret to running high-converting Facebook ads for mortgage brokers

Introduction

Facebook ads can be a goldmine for mortgage brokers—if executed correctly.
While many brokers waste thousands with poor targeting and generic ads, those who master the right strategies consistently generate high-quality leads without blowing their budget.

If you want your Facebook ads to work for you (and not against you), here’s exactly what you need to know.


Understanding the Facebook Algorithm and Targeting Options

The first secret to successful ads is understanding how Facebook’s algorithm matches your ad to potential leads.

  • Facebook’s Goal: Deliver the right content to the right people at the right time.
  • Your Role: Help the algorithm by targeting smartly.

Key targeting strategies:

  • Demographic targeting: Age, location, income level (crucial for mortgage services)
  • Interest targeting: Home ownership, property investment, real estate browsing
  • Behavioral targeting: People actively researching mortgages or financial services

The more precisely you define your audience, the better your ad performance—and the lower your costs.


The Power of Custom Audiences and Lookalike Audiences

Want better leads? Leverage Facebook’s most powerful targeting tools:

  • Custom Audiences:
    Target people who have already interacted with your business—website visitors, email subscribers, video viewers, or past clients.
  • Lookalike Audiences:
    Find new people who share similar traits to your best clients.
    Facebook analyzes your custom audience data and finds a larger group of similar users who are highly likely to be interested in your services.

Tip:
Always test multiple lookalike audiences (1%, 2%, and 5% similarity) to optimize your reach and quality balance.


Creating Attention-Grabbing Ad Copy and Visuals

You only have seconds to grab attention on the Facebook feed.
Your ads must stand out and connect emotionally.

Key tips:

  • Start with a bold hook:
    “Buying your first home? Here’s how to save $20,000 on your mortgage.”
  • Use clean, relatable visuals:
    Photos of happy families, keys in hand, new homes, or even videos explaining the process.
  • Highlight a clear benefit:
    “Lower repayments, faster approvals, personalized service.”
  • Strong CTA (Call to Action):
    “Book a Free Mortgage Consultation Today!”

Authenticity wins over flashy designs. Real images and sincere language perform best in this industry.


Landing Pages That Convert Leads Into Clients

An amazing ad will fail if it leads to a bad landing page.
Your landing page must be fast, clear, and conversion-focused.

Checklist for a high-converting landing page:

  • Headline aligned with your ad promise
  • Short, benefit-driven copy
  • Quick form (name, email, phone)
  • Trust signals (testimonials, logos, certifications)
  • Clear, urgent CTA (“Get Pre-Qualified Now”)

Bonus Tip:
Remove all distractions. No menu bars, no unrelated links. One goal = one action.


Retargeting Strategies to Win Back Warm Leads

Not everyone will convert the first time they see your ad—and that’s OK.
That’s where retargeting comes in.

  • Show ads to website visitors who didn’t fill out the form.
  • Retarget video viewers who watched at least 50% of your educational videos.
  • Offer a second chance with new incentives (“Still looking for the right mortgage? Let’s talk!”)

Retargeting warms up leads and reminds them why they found you valuable in the first place.


Tracking and Optimising Your Ad Performance

Finally, measure everything.
Running Facebook ads without tracking is like flying blind.

Key metrics to monitor:

  • Click-through rate (CTR): Are people engaging with your ad?
  • Cost per lead (CPL): Are you getting leads at a sustainable cost?
  • Conversion rate: Are landing page visitors becoming contacts or clients?

Optimization tips:

  • Kill underperforming ads quickly
  • Test new headlines, images, and CTAs
  • Double down on ads and audiences that perform best

Small tweaks can lead to major improvements over time.


Conclusion

Running high-converting Facebook ads as a mortgage broker isn’t about luck—it’s about strategy, testing, and refinement.
By understanding targeting, creating authentic content, optimizing your landing pages, and tracking your results, you can turn Facebook into a consistent lead-generation engine.

Want to launch a high-converting ad campaign?
Contact us for expert guidance and start getting better results today!

Need Advice For Your Social Media Marketing?

Struggling to make sense of social media strategies or unsure how to connect with your target audience? Our team at Adviser Social Agency specialises in helping professionals like you harness the full potential of social platforms.

Whether it’s building brand authority, growing engagement, or driving real results, we’re here to guide you every step of the way.